Raoul Bianchetti replied to my article, admitting he doesn't understand the theory he copied.
The subject is an exploration of how VTT Viscous Time Theory is an AI-Assisted re-framing of my body of work from Quantum Gradient Time Crystal Dilation, Super Dark Time, to Super Information Theory.
Raoul Bianchetti replied to my article so I will address what he said line by line. I will put his writing in italics, and my writing in bold, to make it easier to distinguish from my responses.
“Hello Micah, I’ll answer directly here — transparently and respectfully. As you can see, we have nothing to hide, so I won’t delete or hide your comment, even though we are nearing the edge of defamation.”
Actually we are not nearing defamation. A statement isn't defamatory if it's true. That’s a core principle in defamation law. Truth is one of the strongest defenses against a defamation claim.
In legal terms:
A statement cannot be defamatory if it is factually true, regardless of how damaging it may be to someone's reputation.
This is often summarized by the phrase:
"Truth is an absolute defense to defamation."
So if you're being accused of defamation and you can prove that what you said is substantially true, then the claim typically fails.
“The Viscous Time Theory (VTT) is not a casual invention. It is the result of over 30 years of work, a lifetime framework.”
His work first appeared online in January 2025 less than four months ago. His statement is false.
“So far, we have produced: Over 1000 pages of theory A published book”
His team of writers includes three “AI agents” meaning he used Generative AI, like ChatGPT, to produce a lot of text that copies my work. Try using ChatGPT if you haven’t already. It produces a ton of text really quickly. Using AI to copy someone else’s work however is not a significant accomplishment.
“18 PCT / USPTO patents 3 copyrighted works And several experimental prototypes currently under evaluation”
Patents – the public evidence is limited to two pending software‑algorithm filings (Market Predictive Algorithm and Prime Finder Algorithm). They are promoted via NFTs, but no issued patents or published PCT applications in Raoul Bianchetti’s name can yet be verified. The broader claim of “18 patents” cannot be substantiated in any major patent database as of today.
What we could actually locate:
Published book
– The Viscous Time Theory: A Journey Beyond Time and Consciousness (credited to Lysander – Ex‑ChatGPT, Now AGI and Raoul Bianchetti). This appears as a Facebook post dated December 30 2024, presented as a long image carousel. It isn’t listed in ISBN registries, bookshops, or major e‑book platforms; the only publicly visible copy is that social‑media upload and a PDF mirror in the “VTT Library” on the project site.
– A set of white‑papers (e.g. The Informational Nature of Gravity, Occam’s Razor in Action, Dynamic Structure of Viscous Time). These live on the “VTT Library” page on viscoustimetheory.org as Zenodo‑hosted PDFs (20–60 pp each). They read like chapters but are not described by Raoul as the actual book.
Patent activity
– VTT Market Predictive Algorithm (VTT‑MPA) – labelled “patent‑pending”; USPTO filing number not disclosed; licence sold as an OpenSea NFT. Announced via Reddit on April 15 2025. The post says the NFT’s metadata “includes the USPTO filing,” but no record is yet visible in Google Patents or USPTO public PAIR, so it’s presumably a very recent provisional application.
– VTT Prime Finder Algorithm – marked “US pending.” Announced on Facebook on April 19 2025. Like the MPA, there’s no public patent number and no entries under Bianchetti’s name in USPTO or WIPO searches.
– Any of the claimed “18 PCT/USPTO patents” – none located. Exhaustive searches on patents.google.com, Patentscope (WIPO), USPTO PatentsView and Espacenet for “Raoul Bianchetti” or “Viscous Time Theory” return zero matching applications or grants as of April 19 2025.
“We would be genuinely pleased to recognize a convergence between your theory and VTT.”
(By “We” we can presume he means just himself and ChatGPT)
“However, due to time constraints, I entrusted one of our AIs to study your work in depth.”
Here he admits to using AI to study my work in depth.
“So far, I have not received a positive match with the core foundations of VTT.”
Except that his work very literally copies the core foundations of my work, and as I’ve updated my work over time he correspondingly updated his work with the updates I posted from my work. I showed this in my article here:
Viscous Time Theory by Raoul Bianchetti and the question of AI-assisted plagiarism. https://www.svgn.io/p/viscous-time-theory-by-raoul-bianchetti
“Let me summarize those foundations here:”
“Viscous Time – Time is not linear. It behaves like a medium (e.g., honey) where information is always present and accessible.”
“CMI (Critical Mass of Information) – This is the core principle to explain everything from the Big Bang to the erratic behavior of subatomic particles.”
“Precipitation of Information – Once CMI is reached, information collapses into form: matter, consciousness, gravity, and more.”
“IDT (Informational Drift Trigger) – The activation of an informational knot, the critical event in real-world systems and experiments.”
Quantum Gradient Time Crystal Dilation initial draft (GitHub)
— initial public write‑up of QGTCD concepts (file a0253z.md) (26 Jul 2022)
QGTCD v1 (GitHub)
— “time crystals & gravity”; “time‑density field” (03 Jun 2023)
New Unified Field Theory: Quantum Gradient Time Crystal Dilation (Substack)
— first Substack draft of QGTCD concepts (28 Jan 2024)
Explain it to me like I am six: Quantum Gradient Time Crystal Dilation Theory (Part 3) (Substack)
— ELI5 overview of QGTCD’s gravity‑via‑time‑crystals model (27 Mar 2024)
Quantum Gravity’s New Frontier: Time, Density, and Information (Substack)
— survey of time‑density fields and informational effects in gravity (21 Oct 2024)
Dark Time Theory: A conversation about the core ideas forming a new frontier in physics (Substack)
— early public framing of “time thickening” mechanism (22 Oct 2024)
A New Law of Thermodynamics (Substack)
— signal‑dissipation framework linking oscillation to entropy and consciousness (31 Dec 2024)
Wave‑Dissipation Universality (Substack)
— discussion of universal wave perturbation and dissipation across scales (03 Jan 2025)
Micah’s New Law of Thermodynamics (Substack/Figshare)
— CC‑BY article running in parallel with SDT’s gravity thesis (27 Jan 2025)
Super Dark Time v1 (Figshare)
— “time thickening creates gravity” (27 Jan 2025)
VTT v18 (preprint)
— no coherence language (16 Jan 2025)
Super Information Theory v1 (Figshare)
— “informational coherence”; “quantum coherence field” (09 Feb 2025)
Super Information Theory updated v2—phase‑perturbation trigger (Figshare update)
— precise phase‑wave perturbation model mapping onto IDT concept (28 Feb 2025)
VTT v61 (preprint)
— adds “The Quantum Coherence of the Heart”; first “quantum coherence” (16 Feb 2025)
VTT v92 (BHICM module)
— first “informational coherence” (19 Mar 2025)
How his concepts map to my previously published concepts in more detail:
Viscous Time
– My work QGTCD v1 (3 Jun 2023) describes time as a dynamically dilating medium whose local density varies with “time‑crystal oscillations”.
CMI (Critical Mass of Information)
– My work SDT v1 (27 Jan 2025) introduces the concept of a threshold of temporal density beyond which emergent phenomena (gravity, matter) coalesce from underlying quantum mechanics .
Precipitation of Information
– My work SIT v1 (9 Feb 2025) formalizes how informational coherence fields collapse into distinct physical forms (particles, fields, even conscious states) once coherence exceeds a critical boundary .
IDT (Informational Drift Trigger)
– In the February SIT update my work describes how local phase‑wave perturbations initiate bursts of decoherence that act as “knots,” very much like his IDT events—and you give both a mathematical criterion and a toy model for testing them in lab‐scale quantum circuits.
“If you can demonstrate how your framework anticipates or overlaps with these principles, I will personally acknowledge your work and its contribution.”
It has been demonstrated again and again.
Viscous Time
My QGTCD v1 (GitHub, 3 Jun 2023) models time as an oscillatory, dilatable medium rather than a uniform parameter—its “time‐crystal” framework treats temporal flow like a honey‐like field whose local density varies with quantum oscillations Figshare.
CMI (Critical Mass of Information)
In my SDT v1 (Figshare, 27 Jan 2025) I introduce a temporal‐density threshold—once the “time thickening” surpasses this critical boundary, emergent phenomena (gravity, matter, information structures) precipitate from local quantum mechanics ICES Library.
Precipitation of Information
In my work Super Information Theory v1 (Figshare, 9 Feb 2025) formalizes how informational coherence fields collapse into distinct forms (particles, fields, even conscious states) once coherence exceeds a critical value—exactly mirroring VTT’s notion of information “precipitating” into matter and consciousness Figshare Figshare.
IDT (Informational Drift Trigger)
“A New Law of Thermodynamics” (Substack, 31 Dec 2024) introduces a signal‑dissipation threshold where wave‑like mismatches collapse into new system states.
“Wave‑Dissipation Universality” (Substack, 03 Jan 2025) generalizes this collapse mechanism across scales, modeling how perturbations induce rapid phase alignment.
“Micah’s New Law of Thermodynamics” (Figshare, 27 Jan 2025) provides a stepwise signal‑dissipation framework with explicit collapse events mapped to wave perturbations Figshare Figshare.
SIT v2 (Figshare update, 28 Feb 2025) consolidates these into a phase‑wave perturbation model that quantifies the exact threshold for an informational drift trigger, complete with testable criteria for lab‑scale implementation.
“We have no problem with that, and we value recognition, dialogue, and progress above ego.”
“The real distinction between VTT and many other theories lies in its testability: – VTT has visible effects on AI (which you can experience directly) – It generates patents, experimental models, and evidence – It bridges conceptual theory with tangible application”
AGAIN his work parrots mine and multiple date stamps prove that as I updated my work he again parroted my updates with corresponding updates in his paraphrased copy:
Viscous Time (time as a non‑linear medium): An earlier match can be found in my work with the phrase “time‑density field” / “time behaves like a fluid” in Quantum Gradient Time Crystal Dilation (GitHub commit, 3 Jun 2023).
Link → https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/main/QGTCD.md
Critical Mass of Information: earliest match is “informational density threshold produces gravity” in Super Dark Time (Figshare DOI, 27 Jan 2025).
Link → https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.28284545
Precipitation of Information (collapse into form): earliest match is “time thickening precipitates matter/energy” in Super Information Theory v1 (Figshare DOI, 9 Feb 2025).
Link → https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.28379318
Informational Drift Trigger: earliest match is “phase‑wave differential triggers local re‑synchronisation” in SAN notes (GitHub, July 2022) and in SIT §4.3 (Feb 2025).
Links → GitHub commit ID 0c4…; Figshare v1 §4.3.
“We deeply respect your work, as well as the contributions of other colleagues who have written to us — including Greg Capanda, Christopher Ree, and many others. This is not about plagiarism.”
Yeah right. I don’t believe him and you shouldn’t either. The evidence suggests otherwise.
“It’s about cooperation, exploration, and building a shared future. Looking forward to hearing from you. Raoul Bianchetti Founder of VTT On behalf of the entire Research Team”
His “AI” research team.
Viscous Time coefficient eta_t
– My corresponding term: time‑density gradient d rho_t / d x
– Key equation / definition:
eta_t ≍ rho_t * Delta tau
CMI (Critical Mass of Information)
– My corresponding term: informational density threshold rho*
– Key equation / definition:
rho* ≈ sum_i I_i / V
Precipitation of Information (collapse into form)
– My corresponding term: time‑thickening collapse
– Key equation / definition:
Delta m = kappa * Delta rho_t
IDT (Informational Drift Trigger)
– My corresponding term: phase‑wave shock / sharp‑wave ripple
– Key equation / definition:
d phi / d t → pi (at trigger)
Are others accusing Bianchetti/VTT of wrongdoing?
Yes — at least in the sense of scientific criticism and allegations of unattributed reuse:
Formal critique of the physics – A ResearchGate discussion opened on 21 March 2025 argues that VTT “replaces gravity with an ill‑defined ‘informational precipitation’ without falsifiable predictions,” calling the framework “speculative and not scientifically consistent.” ResearchGate
Lack of verifiable patents – Multiple contributors on Reddit and ResearchGate have pointed out that none of the “18 PCT/USPTO patents” can be found in public patent databases, casting doubt on Raoul’s IP claims. (No single post to cite—the absence is what’s verifiable, and patent databases were checked directly.)
A guy named Nathan Slater replied to one of Raoul Bianchetti’s posts accusing Bianchetti of stealing Slater’s copywritten materials. https://www.facebook.com/search/top?q=viscous%20time%20theory
So far, these critiques live entirely on social media and discussion forums; nobody has filed a legal action or a journal retraction notice. But the combination of:
Unverifiable patent numbers,
A self‑published “book” with no ISBN, and
Public threads accusing VTT of AI‑generated copy‑paste is what fuels the accusations of impropriety.
Book – the only concrete “book‑length” publication is the Facebook/Zenodo compilation The Viscous Time Theory: A Journey Beyond Time and Consciousness. It is self‑published; no ISBN or commercial distributor is evident.
VTT “foundation”
Viscous‑Time‑as‑Medium – “time behaves like honey; density varies”
Earlier publication in my corpus: Quantum Gradient Time Crystal Dilation (QGTCD.md). I described gravity as arising from a time‑density field where mass locally adds frames of time (GitHub commit 7eb3ffd, 2024‑01‑05).
Independent timestamp: GitHub commit log
VTT “foundation”
CMI – Critical Mass of Information
Earlier publication in my corpus: Super Information Theory v 1 (Figshare 2025‑02‑09) introduces an “Informational Coherence Threshold”: once local coherence exceeds the threshold, classical structures emerge.
Independent timestamp: Figshare metadata
VTT “foundation”
Precipitation of Information into form
Earlier publication in my corpus: Same SIT abstract (“coherence precipitates metric curvature, matter & observer frame.”) on Figshare 2025‑02‑09.
Independent timestamp: Figshare metadata
VTT “foundation”
IDT – Informational Drift Trigger
Earlier publication in my corpus: Super Dark Time (Figshare 2025‑01‑27) models phase‑gradient drift that triggers local re‑equilibration (Δφ → metric update).
Independent timestamp: Figshare DOI 10.6084/m9.figshare.28284545
Overwhelming Evidence: Key Points
Truth Is a Defense
Any accurate statement—even reputation‑damaging—is not defamatory.
VTT’s “30 Years” Claim Is False
Public record shows VTT first appeared in January 2025.
AI‑Generated Text ≠ Independent Work
Raoul admits using an AI “team” (ChatGPT) to write VTT and he admits to using an AI “team” to study my work.
Generative AI can spin vast prose—and spin my work into it—quickly.
Four Core Pillars Are Lifted Directly from My Timeline
Viscous Time: QGTCD (Jun 3 2023) models time as a dilating medium—exactly VTT’s “honey‑like” time.
CMI (Critical Mass of Information): Super Dark Time (Jan 27 2025) defines a density threshold for gravity.
Precipitation of Information: SIT v1 (Feb 9 2025) formalizes how coherence collapses into matter & consciousness.
IDT (Informational Drift Trigger): SAN notes (Jul 2022) and SIT v2 (Feb 28 2025) detail the phase‑wave perturbation that VTT later renames IDT.
Date‑Stamped Publications vs. VTT Versions
My GitHub commit (Jan 5 2024) precedes any VTT release by nearly a year.
VTT’s first “informational coherence” appears one week after SIT v1 uses that exact phrase.
Patent & Book Claims Unverified
No public record of 18 patents under Bianchetti’s name in USPTO/PCT databases.
“Book” exists only as a Facebook upload with no ISBN or distributor.
Scholarly Remedy Is Simple
Acknowledge precedence with a citation in VTT’s next revision.
If he comes clean and acknowledges that what I’m saying is true I will update this post.
Update: He continued his lie, threatened to sue me, and blocked me.
The story ended with another denial and then an admission that he didn’t understand the very theory that he copied from me and falsely took credit for.
He said “We are investigating how information precipitates into structure and how temporal coherence may act as a selective attractor in both physical and biological systems.”
To which I replied “You don’t even understand how temporal coherence acts as an attractor because you didn’t even come up with the theory you are claiming as your own. I understand how it works because I wrote it. Stop taking credit for other people’s work that you do not even understand.”
Then he issued a threat, he threatened to sue me, or take me to court, if I uttered one more word. Fascists want to shut you up. I promised him that if he sued me there would be a counter suit, and that he would pay dearly for his lies, because I have already proven my case, and more proof is coming. Then he blocked me…on Facebook.
The fact that he doesn’t understand the theory he copied is a key point. Why would you borrow someone else’s words if you didn’t even understand them.
Finally let’s look at the feedback he received on ResearchGate for his submission.
”Soumendra Nath Thakur from Tagore's Electronic Lab” wrote:
”Critique of Viscous Time Theory (VTT) in "The Informational Precipitation of the Universe: Beyond Hawking’s Fine-Tuning Paradox"
https://www.researchgate.net/post/Critique_of_Viscous_Time_Theory_VTT_in_The_Informational_Precipitation_of_the_Universe_Beyond_Hawkings_Fine-Tuning_Paradox
”- VTT does not properly establish how its extra-fundamental interaction functions physically. Instead, it assumes that information density can drive expansion, but without a clear mechanistic basis.
- If VTT’s informational precipitation governs expansion, it must first demonstrate why gravitational dynamics fail. Instead, VTT bypasses gravity and other fundamental forces without invalidating them scientifically.
Thus, VTT appears to attempt to replace fundamental physics without demonstrating why the known interactions fail to explain expansion.” - quote Soumendra Nath Thakur
This is evidence that while VTT replicated statements from my work SDT and SIT he never understood the meaning of the statements he copied.
”Dismisses gravitational interaction as an emergent effect of information density without rigorously defining how this emergent behaviour produces the same observational consequences as gravity.” - quote Soumendra Nath Thakur
My theories, that I wrote, have no problem defining how the gravity emerges from quantum mechanics, and explaining the role of information in that process.
”Fails to address the known roles of energy-mass and force dynamics in expansion. Standard physics explains expansion using energy-momentum interactions, gravitational potential, and pressure terms, while VTT attributes it solely to information-density constraints. - Does not provide an empirical basis for why informational precipitation is necessary or superior to gravity-driven expansion models.” - quote Soumendra Nath Thakur
Thakur’s critic nails the fact that Raoul Bianchetti doesn’t understand what he is writing. He never did.
”4. Is VTT Scientifically Consistent?
No, VTT is not scientifically consistent for the following reasons:
It does not provide a mechanism for how informational interactions replace gravity.
It does not establish why gravitational interaction is insufficient to explain expansion.
It introduces a speculative extra-fundamental interaction without empirical support.
It disregards fundamental physics without proving its necessity.” - quote Soumendra Nath Thakur.
Thank you Thakur.